Unconventional thinking about the Middle East.

Saturday, January 13, 2007

Sadrists and Sex Orgies

See, I thought long and hard about writing about this topic, since it may smut-‘tify’ Talisman Gate, but I think it is relevant: it demonstrates just how much the Sadrist movement is actually a symptom of a weird cult that’s sprung up in Najaf.

Before reading any further, kindly go through this post that I had written back in May 2006 about the so-called Sulukiyya sect—very relevant to what is to come.

I found this most recent fatwa (dated November 25, 2005), where Muqatada al-Sadr signs off on Mahdi Army-sponsored sex orgies, posted on a jihadist website that is very much anti-Shi'a. It was being used by the jihadists to demonstrate the supposed depravity of all Shi'as. Apparently a picture of the fatwa has been floating around jihadist websites for several months now, but this is the first I see of it. Given the source, the document would be highly suspect—someone may be trying to libel the Sadrists. However, the wording of Sadr’s fatwa seems authentic and in keeping with the usual style employed in such matters. It also bears his seal. However, all this can be concocted by a jihadist (…or a Hakim follower) with some reasonable knowledge of writing up Shi'a fatwas and with Photoshop. But given what I’ve heard about the Sulukiyya sect, I am inclined to believe that it is authentic.

The fatwa was covered by the Saudi-owned alarabiya.net (I don’t know if it was carried on its TV programming—doubt it) on December 5, 2006, and in it the Sadrists vehemently deny the fatwa’s authenticity on the grounds that Muqtada does not have the clerical seniority to issue fatwas (this is false, he has issued plenty of ‘instructions’ that carry the weight of fatwas among his followers), and that muta’a (see below for definition) rules cannot apply under any legal frameworks to group orgies. This makes sense since the offspring of muta’a marriages are considered legitimate, and there are strict rules to match pregnancies to husbands even if the temporary marriage would have lasted but a few hours. However, in practice, muta’a marriages are a form of prostitution and ‘rules’ fly out the window where there’s money to be made. The Sadrist naysayer quoted in the Arabiya piece also implies that this was produced by someone trying to tarnish the Mahdi Army and to foment dissent between Muqtada and another leading rival cleric, al-Ya’aqoubi (see below).

But even with this denial, the fatwa still seems plausible to me: it would be something that Muqtada would author if he were indeed influenced by the Sulukiyya sect as I’ve been told, and as is heavily rumored among the mainstream clerics in Najaf. But still, the strongest case lending this fatwa to being a forgery would be that it does not deal with the issue of who fathers the offspring.

Here’s my translation, with explanations in italics and parentheses:

In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful,

His Benevolence hujjet al-islam wel muslimeen [Ed.: clerical rank below that of Ayatollah] the mujahid Seyyid Muqtada al-Sadr (Honored by Allah):

[Dear] mujahid Seyyid, May Allah Preserve You:

We are a group of Zaynebite [Ed.: in Arabic, zaynebiyyat, in reference to Zaynab bint ‘Ali, daughter of the patron saint of Shi’ism, Imam Ali, through his wife, Fatima al-Zahra, daughter of the Prophet Muhammad. Zaynab was the most senior member of Muhammad’s family to survive the massacre at Karbala, and she was turned into an iconic female figure in early Shi’ism. Her popularity is reflected in the number of alleged burial tombs that she has; one in Cairo, another in Medina, and yet a third south of Damascus] devotees who support the Mahdi Army (‘May Allah Hasten the Advent of the Mahdi’) and we would like to ask Your Benevolence, hujjet al-islam wel muslimeen, Seyyid Muqtada al-Sadr, May Allah Preserve him, about an invitation extended to us by the [Mahdi Army] to attend a [group sex orgy] [Ed.: in Arabic, haflet muta’ah jama’iyyeh, with ‘muta’ah,’ literally meaning ‘pleasure,’ being the accepted practice of temporary marriage in Shi'a Islam; whereby a marriage is set for a temporary period of time and for a fixed dowry, and does not need the consent of parents if the wife is not a virgin. Any issue or progeny from the marriage is considered legitimate offspring] at a certain husseiniya [Ed.: a Shi'a place of worship and ritual]. And they said that the [spiritual] bonus of a [sex orgy] is seventy times as much as an individual muta’a. We consulted one of the seyyids [Ed.: descendants of Muhammad] who represents Sheikh Muhammad al-Ya’aqoubi [Ed.: the followers of Muqtada’s father split among the majority that continues to support Muqtada, and a minority that supports Sheikh Ya’aqoubi, who is the spiritual head of the Fadhila Party, which controls two dozen seats in parliament)] about [sex orgies] but he denied knowing anything about this type of muta’a and said that it is an innovation [Ed.: the usual connotation of an ‘innovation,’ bida’a,' is negative]. Is it lawful to have [sex orgies]? Given that it is limited to several hours only (that is, less than one night), and the purpose of this orgy is to fulfill the desires of the Mahdi Army, specifically of those who cannot [find] intercourse due to the distraction of doing battle with the nawasib [Ed.: derogatory Shi'a term for Sunnis, connoting hostility to the progeny of Muhmmad], and that the revenue from this [orgy] will go towards providing the Mahdi Army with arms. Answer us may Allah reward you with the best of rewards.

The Zaynebite
Azhar Hassan al-Fartousi
On behalf of a group of Zaynebites
17 Shawwal 1426 [Ed.: November 19, 2005]

[Response: ]

In His Blessed Name

It is known that the muta’a marriage is blessedly accepted in our creed and the nawasib have tried to make us skeptical about it and to bar us from it; for fear that the sons of our sect will increase [in number] and we may become a mighty force, therefore we call upon the children of our creed not to be discomfited by anything to do with muta’a marriage. Holding [sex orgies] is one of the matters that have been made allowable by our higher authorities but by taking due notice that no non-Muslims are allowed to enter, along with laypersons, into those orgies so as not to view the taboos of our [female] devotees; and that is probably why the seyyid [who speaks for] al-Ya’aqoubi frowns upon it. That said, it is [also] known that having muta’a with one of the soldiers of the [Mahdi Army] is more [spiritually] beneficial than [having it] with others because [the soldier] is sacrificing his blood for the advent of the [Mahdi] therefore we ask the Zaynebites not to be stingy with what Allah has given them by way of physical attributes and money. We ask our sister the Zaybebite to refer to one of our [official] representatives to seek permission to hold these [orgies] so that they would be under the strict supervision and control by the [Mahdi Army]. May Allah reward you the best of rewards.

[Sealed with Muqtada al-Sadr’s official seal]

[Signed, Muqtada al-Sadr]

[Dated:] 23 Shawwal 1426 [Ed.: 25 November 2005]

Now we have all this talk in Washington and Baghdad about the need to confront the Mahdi Army militias and their death squads. I’ve recently written about the fragmentation of the Mahdi Army, as well as some bizarre cases of members who were originally Sunni or Ba’athist.

It is important to remember that the Muqtada al-Sadr movement is an aberration in Shi’ism, but that such aberrations are nothing new. There is an inner circle around Muqtada that has seriously convinced itself that the Mahdi, or Messiah, is about to emerge out of occultation, and that the Mahdi could either be Muqtada himself (I mentioned this here once; Muqtada’s father would be the nafs al-zekiyya in this line of thinking) or that Muqtada is one of the ‘signs’ of this messianic advent. We’ve seen this multiple times in every era of Shi'a history; the last major disturbance was the Babi movement of Seyyid Ali Muhammad al-Shirazi in 1844-1850, who seized upon the embitterment of the Sheykhi faction of Shi’ism (…more mystical in its approach to religious texts; lost out to the Usuli school of scriptural interpretation, which is more literal in its methodology and reigns supreme in Najaf and Qum to this day) to unleash a messianic movement that spread throughout Iran and Iraq, and eventually morphed into the Baha’i faith.

Moreover, this business of sex orgies has been around as a ready epithet against Shi'as and all heterodox Muslim sects for a long time. Sunni orthodoxy has always employed this accusation to highlight the alleged depravity of Shi'as: in Ottoman times, the Kizilbash were denounced as ‘mumsondu’—literally, ‘the candle is out’—in reference to the rite, which still survives among Turkey’s Alevis, of putting out three lit candles at the end of the cem (the Alevi form of prayer where Shi'a symbols are employed but not proper Islamic prayers) ritual. Because cem rituals feature men and women praying and dancing together, the imagination of Sunnis led them to believe that the communal gathering would break out into an orgy after the candles are out. Modern Sunni Turks still believe the Alevis are ‘mumsondu.’ I attended two cem rituals this summer, but alas, no orgies.

The same accusation has been made against the Nusayris/‘Alawites of Syria and Turkey’s Hatay province, even though this sect does not perform anything like the cem ritual. The accusation here has more to do with the pre-Islamic fertility cults that were dominant along the interior of the Mediterranean coast: in Hatay, this was centered around the temple complex at the waterfalls of Daphne, now situated in the town of Harbiyye, where the temple ‘nuns’ would offer their sexual services for the pleasure of the paying ‘supplicants,’ and the money would go towards the upkeep of the shrine. The town of Harbiyye and the surrounding mountain villages are exclusively Nusayri/Alawite. Note: I went there this summer too, and no orgies either. Strike two.

My favorite ‘there’s-no-smoke-without-a-fire’ echo of this accusation concerns the temple of ‘Afqa at the very top of the Nahr Ibrahim valley in Lebanon. This temple was dedicated to the Greek deity Adonis, who has other Levantine and Egyptian manifestations and was worshipped under different names. Myth had it that ‘Afqa was the site where Adonis was slain by a wild boar, and the stream (especially the one emerging from the nearby spring in the village of Mugheiriya) turns red every Spring. That has more to do with the increased torrent of the water after the rain season (which churns out reddish mud) than with any mythical magic, but that didn’t really matter to the religious pilgrims who followed a route along the northern ridge of the Nahr Ibrahim valley dotted with ‘way’ shrines. The 'nuns' at the temple of Afqa employed the same set-up as at the waterfalls of Daphne: sex for alms. The Byzantines tried to stamp out this cult, but it apparently stuck. Then Islam came along, and the villages, especially in the vicinity, took up some Islamic symbols, specifically Shi'a ones, to mask their pagan faith (…this is my theory, at least). But afterwards the Mamlukes of Syria—who were fired up by the Damascene religious fanatic Ibn Taymiyya—ran expeditions into the mountains of Kisrawan seven hundred years ago, and massacred many crypto-Shi'as; most of the survivors headed east and settled the harder-to-defend Beka’a Valley (…where they remain today). These depopulated mountainous areas that were left behind were soon taken up with the expanding Christian Maronite communities to the north around the Qadisha Valley (…who now claim Kisrawan as their heartland).

But here’s the interesting thing: the village of Afqa is still 100 percent Shi'a today. Most of the villages along the northern pilgrimage route are still majority Shi'a or with large Shi'a minorities (living among Maronites). There are Shi'a pockets nearby in all Maronite country. The history of human spirituality shows than people can remain very sentimental about holy places; Shi’ism may have survived in these villages after the Mamluke massacres because the villagers may still have been attached to their pagan roots (…and the money that would have been generated in the olden times from pilgrims). My own theory is that prior to becoming mainstream Shi’as, these villages would have believed in something akin to what some of the surviving ‘Alawite sects in Syria adhere to, but then would have come under the influence of the mainstream Shi'a centers of learning in Jabal ‘Amil, in southern Lebanon. Ahem, ahem, no orgies in Afqa either, or at least none when I went exploring last spring. Damn you jihadists and your misleading and outdated propaganda about Shi'a orgies!

Could those aforementioned Zaynebites be the latter-day priestesses of Afqa and Daphne? I know, I know: it's a stretch. But the jihadists who are cross-posting Muqtada's fatwa on their sites certainly seem to think so.

So in conclusion, weirder things have happened in Shi'a history, and similar accusations have been made, way before the publication of this alleged fatwa being attributed to Muqtada. The rumors about the Sulukiyya cult ring true, and one needs to view the Sadrists as a historical aberration—albeit one with Kalashnikovs, cell phones, websites, and cabinet ministries. They will survive as a weird, marginal sub-sect of Shi’ism, and will be remain nuisance for the mainstreamers of Najaf. But that’s about it: they are a nuisance, and not a real threat. Which means that their growth potential is limited. Which means that they can be isolated and confronted. Which means now.


Anonymous exile - iraqi / gilgamesh X said...

Very good Nibras !

Very good post, you're the first one who roughly sees ME history as a continuum. All the others, the MSM orientalists, think that Islam imposed something new, that there was a break but actually all things flow from Antique history to Medieval and today. And Islam was just a new skin like with those Russian puppets.

Very good post !

5:58 PM, January 13, 2007

Blogger Bloodstomper Barbie said...

Thanks you so much for some of the most enlightening prose on the internet.

8:15 PM, January 13, 2007

Blogger Robert said...

Great post Nibras. I've long suspected, but am now convinced, that Moqtada's religous grotesqueness rivals that of Franklin Jones (aka Da-Love Ananda, Adi Da).

11:19 PM, January 13, 2007

Anonymous yessir said...


Just thought this would be an interesting tidbit to go along with this post... Professor Juan Cole, on his blog, made a mention of rumors concerning the alleged homosexuality of Muqtada (it's alleged his wife left him because he
s gay). http://www.juancole.com/2007/01/apocalypse-ii-in-samarra-us-kills-6-at.html

Have you heard anything about this? If so, what do you make of it?

3:15 AM, January 15, 2007

Anonymous lester said...

like all your topics, this is based on a ridiculous posting on the presitgious iternet, not a reliable source. you said last week that haniyeh had refused to pray wit hshias and supported it by some ridiculous fatwa pulled from a web forum. meanwhile, haniyeh did pray with the shias, just not specific prayers. i have the pictures. and their was no fatwa in fact hamas praised Iran in actual newspapers today.

4:09 PM, January 16, 2007

Anonymous Anonymous said...

so lester you can read arabic???

and you support hizullah???

and you support insurgency???

and you are anonymus???

is anyone thinking what i am thinking???

8:18 PM, January 16, 2007

Blogger Nibras Kazimi نبراس الكاظمي said...

Hi Yessir,

I haven't heard this rumor. Muqtada is married to his distant cousin, the daughter of Seyyid Muhammad Baqir al-Sadr (who was executed by Saddam in 1980), according to a source.

I haven't heard that she had left him. I've never heard that he's gay.

I have misgivings about the source you cited; the anecdotal information and analysis is more often than not incorrect.



9:19 AM, January 17, 2007

Anonymous GAWAD said...

Juan Cole thinks he is an Iraq expert because he can assign people with the following labels:

* Shi'i
* Sunni
* Kurd

Oh, and he has been to an Arab country before (not Iraq), so he is a total Iraq expert.


4:50 PM, January 21, 2007

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Check it out

3:14 PM, February 01, 2007

Blogger 一笑千年 said...

Comfort Roger Vivier rtdjgnthj can aid in walking when it gets tough because of pain.Other things you can do to help Achilles tendinitis is with cold compression therapy and certain exercises. Heel pads added to vivier shoes can also help take some of the strain off that tendon.Work vivier shoes are often constricting and stiff. If you have foot discomfort or problems, whether it be minor or stemming from something more serious, then footcare is nothing to take lightly. Orthopedic roger vivier heels will make a significant difference in comfort level and in health. roger vivier flats with slip resistance or athletic vivier shoes will prevent things like scrapes and blisters on your heel and toes. This is especially useful for bike-riding and inclines.Particular sack was looked becausethe vivier shoes blog roger vivier pumps on sale patch was near the middlesex county and somerset county camouflage.I'm not sure Will Blog for roger vivier sale is where I need to be right now. I'm in such a different place than I was four years ago. I think it's the whole "vivier shoes" thing. I used to buy A. Lot. Of. vivier shoes. I don't anymore. Actually, when I think about the number of roger vivier chaussures that used to be packed in my tiny little closet, I want to throw up. Today, I buy when I need (to be honest, it's tough for me to buy even then).

2:02 AM, August 10, 2011

Anonymous price per head service said...

Hilariously cool. I have been looking for sites like this for a long time. Thank you my friend.

12:09 PM, June 11, 2012

Anonymous call center voip solutions said...

Reading this info So i am happy to convey that I’ve an incredibly good uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed. I most certainly will make certain to do not forget this web site and give it a glance on a constant basis.

2:12 PM, August 13, 2012

Anonymous Agen Bola Sbobet said...

Hey, just looking around some blogs, seems a pretty nice platform you are using. I'm currently using Wordpress for a few of my sites but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it? Agen Sbobet Agen Ibcbet

1:20 PM, June 20, 2013

Anonymous Agen Bola said...

This is a fantastic website and I can not recommend you guys enough. Full of useful resource and great layout very easy on the eyes.

4:59 PM, December 29, 2013

Blogger dong dong23 said...

tods outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
christian louboutin outlet
longchamp handbags
michael kors outlet
louis vuitton
jordan shoes
jordan retro
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet clearance
jordan 4
jordan 13
coach factory outlet
ray bans
true religion
nike outlet
tiffany outlet
cheap jordans
michael kors canada
michael kors outlet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
fake watches
supra shoes
jordan 6
nike outlet store
toms shoes
ralph lauren outlet
nike air max
jordan 4 toro
louis vuitton outlet
air jordan pas cher
ray ban sunglasses outlet
coach outlet store online
ray ban sunglasses
kate spade handbags
oakley vault
true religion outlet
oakley sunglasses wholesale
coach outlet store online clearances

7:00 PM, June 07, 2016

Blogger Fangyaya said...

louis vuitton outlet
nike trainers
timberland boots
jordan 8
adidas uk
air max 90
louboutin pas cher
oakley sunglasses
cheap oakley sunglasses
tory burch outlet
adidas nmd
burberry outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores
ralph lauren uk
coach factory outlet
nike air force
coach outlet
michael kors outlet online
burberry outlet
kate spade outlet
kevin durant shoes 8
ray ban sunglasses outlet
polo ralph lauren
replica watches
michael kors outlet
celine bags
fitflop sandals
christian louboutin wedges
lebron james shoes 13
coach outlet online
michael kors purses
yeezy boost 350
instyler curling iron
coach outlet store online
christian louboutin shoes
christian louboutin outlet
true religion shorts
timberland shoes
coach factory outlet

1:43 AM, July 25, 2016

Blogger 艾丰 said...

hollister clothing
coach outlet
hollister uk
coach outlet
kate spade handbags
vans outlet
cheap michael kors handbags
nike roshe
michael kors handbags
ugg boots clearance
nike air force 1
soccer jerseys wholesale
ugg outlet store
chicago blackhawks
adidas uk
michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors outlet
oakley sunglasses
cheap nhl jerseys
michael kors outlet clearance
ralph lauren outlet
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
tiffany outlet
fitflops clearance
louboutin pas cher
toms outlet
uggs outlet
michael kors handbags
polo ralph lauren
michael kors outlet online
ralph lauren,polo ralph lauren,ralph lauren outlet,ralph lauren italia,ralph lauren sito ufficiale
puma outlet
true religion jeans

1:28 AM, August 18, 2016


Post a Comment

<< Home