Unconventional thinking about the Middle East.

Sunday, August 16, 2009

No wonder counter-insurgency is faltering in the Mosul area...

Chalk this up to the "Do you know the enemy?" syndrome. From the New York Times today, 'Minorities Can't Escape Fury of Northern Iraq's Ethnic and Religious Maelstrom,' Sunday, August 16, 2009:

Maj. Gen. Robert L. Caslen Jr., commander of American forces in northern Iraq, told reporters on Tuesday that the Sunni insurgent group Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia had now teamed up with another militant group, the Islamic State of Iraq.
I'm guessing that Gernal Caslen and his briefers are not regular readers of Talisman Gate. This guy is supposed to be battling the jihadists in and around Mosul, yet he manages to get a critical piece of information so wrong, which makes me wonder, what else is he getting wrong?

'Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia' created the Islamic State of Iraq in October 2006, nearly three years ago. It subsumed itself into the new organization, and there hasn't been something called 'Al-Qaeda in Mesopotamia' since that time. Kindly update your briefing folders.

13 Comments:

Anonymous Faisal Kadri said...

Yes, this is really funny. But you can't point your finger at your allies at the time of war and accuse them of working against you ;)

5:35 AM, August 18, 2009

 
Anonymous amagi said...

Well, Nibras, what happens now?

8:20 PM, August 19, 2009

 
Anonymous Sam said...

Looks like Dagher got it wrong again in the write-up of the Baghdad blasts. He says "affiliate," which is somewhat closer than Caslen's characterization that Dagher passed on without comment or correction, but still wrong.

My view is that you are right, technically, that there is no more AQ fi bilad al-rafidayn. ISI is the correct title from the standpoint of ISI, what they want to call themselves. But I think it's acceptable journalistic shorthand to continue to say "Al-Qaida," and just leave out any mention of ISI altogether, since 1) it's confusing and requires explanation 2) it's a pretty ridiculous pretense for them to say they're a state and 3) their goals, methods, leaders and networks with international jihadis are 95% the same as AQ's, if not more.

But if you continue to use the term AQ, don't use ISI as well, and certainly don't give the impression that they're separate organizations.

8:34 PM, August 19, 2009

 
Blogger Anand said...

I saw Maj. Gen. Robert L. Caslen's briefing. I think you are misinterpreting his comments. He knows about the Islamic State in Iraq.

In any case, most US troops were pulled out of Mosul in late 2006, and haven't gone back in significant numbers. Mosul has been a primarily IA and IP affair ever since.

6:28 PM, August 22, 2009

 
Blogger Nibras Kazimi نبراس الكاظمي said...

Hi Anand,

Kindly provide a link. All I have to go on is how Caslen sounded in the New York Times story. He sounded misinformed.

Best,

Nibras

9:28 AM, August 24, 2009

 
Blogger lilena said...

Endometriosis pain, treatment endometriosis, symptoms of endometriosis.endometriosis

3:26 AM, November 26, 2009

 
Blogger lilena said...

Gynecomastia treatment, gynecomastia causes, gynecomastia cure, male breast enlargement guide.gynecomastia

3:26 AM, November 26, 2009

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ACER Aspire 7110 Series Laptop BatteryACER Aspire 7110 Series Laptop Battery
ACER Aspire 9300 Series Laptop BatteryACER Aspire 9300 Series Laptop Battery
ACER Aspire 9400 Series Laptop BatteryACER Aspire 9400 Series Laptop Battery
ACER Aspire 9410 Series Laptop BatteryACER Aspire 9410 Series Laptop Battery
ACER Aspire 9420 Series Laptop BatteryACER Aspire 9420 Series Laptop Battery
ACER TravelMate 4220 Series Laptop BatteryACER TravelMate 4220 Series Laptop Battery
ACER TravelMate 5100 Series Laptop BatteryACER TravelMate 5100 Series Laptop Battery
ACER TravelMate 5110 Series Laptop BatteryACER TravelMate 5110 Series Laptop Battery

9:53 PM, August 03, 2010

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ACER TravelMate 5600 Series Laptop BatteryACER TravelMate 5600 Series Laptop Battery
ACER TravelMate 5610 Series Laptop BatteryACER TravelMate 5610 Series Laptop Battery
ACER TravelMate 5620 Series Laptop BatteryACER TravelMate 5620 Series Laptop Battery
Dell 312-0090 BatteryDell 312-0090 Battery
Dell 312-0408 BatteryDell 312-0408 Battery
Dell 451-10133 BatteryDell 451-10133 Battery
Dell 9X821 BatteryDell 9X821 Battery
Dell Inspiron 510m BatteryDell Inspiron 510m Battery
Dell Inspiron 600m Series BatteryDell Inspiron 600m Series Battery
Dell Latitude D500 SeriesDell Latitude D500 Series

10:04 PM, August 03, 2010

 
Blogger MulberryNews said...

Famous The movies Oakley Sunglasses Outlet superstars who vftbieg are well-known with regard to their higher Half X sensibility to style richly present Oakley Stpl Jawbone clear of this tendency. Oversized Oakley Jawbone are capturing consideration interior previous all this pattern has as a final point used it is Sale Oakley Sunglasses soil typically. But as per style pioneers opt for the just almost Oakley Sunglasses Discount which meets you very good. A extensive a number of Half X Oakley which might be during come july 1st time Oakley Sunglasses Cheap might be viewed featuring with many colour and might be viewed in numerous outlines in addition to sizes.

9:24 PM, July 22, 2011

 
Blogger Half X Oakley said...

You may want to track vgebhty down nicely made Oakley Sunglasses Cheap using excellent skiing conditions helmets Half X Oakley for you to supplement his or her sporty search. There exists merely one Oakley Sunglasses Discount pertaining to shopper decide on as part of your past Sale Oakley Sunglasses ages. Effectively, the idea tend not to visual appeal that will desired somehow. Nevertheless Oakley Jawbone right now, customers employ a a lot superior alternative: Oakley Stpl Jawbone. Half X while their concept demonstrates could make the thing is that evident though preserving way up your current sight via Oakley Sunglasses Outlet highly effective sun rays.

11:38 PM, July 26, 2011

 
Blogger Half X said...

You can virtual vbghtyfc the Oakley Sunglasses Cheap which you have chosen on Half X Oakley the similar model with your face shape. It can Oakley Sunglasses Discount help you choose a pair of suitable and fashionable Sale Oakley Sunglasses. You also can virtual them on Oakley Jawbone your own pictures after you upload your pictures on your computer. These prescription Oakley Stpl Jawbone are designed by different face shape, skin tones, colors and personalities, all of these can help you find a pair of ideal Half X. Wearing a pair of prescription Oakley Sunglasses Outlet will be fashionable and suitable.

3:20 AM, August 05, 2011

 
Blogger monstercq said...

Yeah, that's good.
As well, I'm not sure what direction to go, then, together with her fingers your sweetheart proclaimed Buffalo Monthly bills #34 Top patting any NFL NIKE Jerseys desk: Gday, useless woman!Don't know just who Now i'm Won't cheap Arizona Cardinals jerseys be able to you find a sharp, premiered to mix goodness me!

2:44 AM, October 15, 2012

 

Post a Comment

<< Home