Unconventional thinking about the Middle East.

Monday, January 04, 2010

Re-inventing Talisman Gate; Iran and Iraq’s Election

I don’t get it. After six years of being in the news, why is Hazim al-Araji’s name still mangled in transliteration? Why does it become “Hazim al-Araaiy” on the front-page of the Washington Post today, especially when his Canadian residency spells it correctly in English?

What’s more, why is he misidentified as “a Shiite lawmaker who heads the conservative Sadrist bloc in parliament,” when he isn’t even a member of parliament. It’s easy to spot where the reporter, Ernesto Londono, who’s been covering Iraq for several years, went wrong: he conflated Hazim al-Araji with Baha’ al-Araji. Honest mistake, except for Londono’s track record, which has established him in my eyes as one of the worst of the lot of mediocre journos pushing anti-war agendas in their reporting on Iraq.

Londono, after all, is the kind of reporter that manages to find sorrow in a cemetery. No small feat. And then has the sublimely confident sense to write about it.

Part of this blog’s mission over the years was to ‘call-out’ Western reporters covering Iraq for dishonest bias or misguided comprehension of emerging trends.

As some of you old-timers have noticed, the fire’s out here at Talisman Gate. The passion is gone, mostly because whatever gets written by such reporters and analysts makes absolutely no difference to Iraq’s trajectory: Iraq is heading to safety, and the stories of that land are those of the boring, very local variety.

For example, the state of political flux in Iraq is beautifully bizarre and complex. It really is a work of art, made more aesthetically pleasing by the realization that as issues settle and sediment, they lay the foundation for long-term stability and civil peace. But I don’t understand why an American audience would need to read about how new politics is taking shape in the Iraqi countryside. What American audiences need to know is that last month, not a single U.S. soldier died in combat. Unfortunately, U.S. papers don’t seem to cover that.

The last hurrah of the activist reporters in Iraq has nothing to do with Iraq: they needed to hammer on the negativism—some even writing about how U.S. soldiers are ‘littering’ in Iraq—so as to influence the Afghanistan ‘surge’ debate. They needed to argue that Iraq was an unmitigated disaster despite America’s best efforts, ergo there’s no need to even attempt to fix things in Afghanistan.

I doubt that after the March elections there would be compelling reasons for any U.S. media outlet to maintain a bureau in Baghdad. And good riddance.

So let’s re-invent Talisman Gate as something else: not as a pulpit that argues that Iraq will make it, but a sounding board for ideas about how Iraq will transform its neighborhood.

And let’s get things started by asking, how will the protests in Iran be influenced by a successful and fair election in Iraq?

I must admit that it took a recent photograph of an Iranian demonstrator kicking a policeman to get me excited about the prospects of change in Tehran. I was resigned to the idea that Iran, much like Egypt, is a rotting carcass with no signs of life. I now believe I was wrong.

Keeping things simple, Iraqi elections occur on March 7, and we’d probably have the results in by the 17th. The Persian New Year is March 21st, and it is no stretch to predict that the Iranian opposition will attempt to hold rallies on that date.

The image of a democratic and predominately Shiite Iraq holding fair elections will be a stark contrast to Iran’s recent experience with ballots. I’d imagine that if I were a person with a stake in the Iranian ruling establishment, I’d be very worried about having Iranians draw the wrong conclusions from that image. The idea that the sages of Shiism in Najaf such as Sistani & Co., who are supposed to tend to business while the Hidden Imam is away (…the very premise of the ruling order in Tehran), giving the Iraqi election their stamp of approval is an existential threat to the legitimacy of the Ahmadinejad/Revolutionary Guard order.

This would not be the first time that power in Iran was undermined by actors and ideas operating in Iraq; lots of that was happening in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Set aside all the differing variables, and the very real hatred between Iranians and Iraqis, but it would be an easy leap for the Iranian opposition to draw inspiration for the stances of the aesthetics of Najaf vis-à-vis tyrannical power. Iranians might hold their noses up at the idea of being inspired by ‘locust-eating’ Iraqis, but Sistani’s thumbs up on behalf of the Mahdi for how things are unfolding in Iraq will be a powerful revelation.

So if I am threatened by such an event on the calendar, what would I do?

Well, I’ve heard that preparations are underway to protest election fraud. Whispers about tent cities blockading the entrances to the Green Zone, and busloads of bored teenagers decanted from Sadr City into them. Somebody is coming up with a non-violent action plan for the day after the election results are announced. They assume that they will do badly, and are determined to make an inelegant exit.

I’m not saying that the Iranians are behind this; any dominant political force, seeing its fortunes waning, must make the claim that a drumming at the ballots had more to do with fraud than voters turning against them. On the face it, such protests jump-start a period of noisy opposition by those ejected from power. But it is also clear to see how the Iranian authorities may benefit from such theatrics in Iraq: they can point to events there and say to their people, “The Iraqi elections are also tainted, and Iraqis are also protesting in the street.” This scenario is certainly better for them than Iraqi elections going smoothly, reaping benefits to the Shiites after centuries of injustice, under the auspices of the Great Satan nonetheless.

So mark your calendars folks: Iraqi elections may become a rallying cry for demonstrators in Tehran, and the rulers of Iran may point to, or provoke, protests in Baghdad to taint any positive images of purple fingers and content voters streaming out from polls in Karbala and Basra.

I must add that re-inventing Talisman Gate does not necessarily mean that the pace of posting will pick-up. So don't get your hopes up. However, I would like to thank the loyal readers who have been harassing me these past months to begin writing again; your passion about these topics compels me to respond and deliver.

I promise to convey some sense of election fever in Iraq over the next couple of months. Stay tuned.

21 Comments:

Anonymous Justice/Basil said...

Great post Nibras. I'm sure I speak on behalf of many of your loyal readers when I say that we are all sad to see you slow down your pace of posting. Best of luck to you in all your endeavors!

Basil

P.S. Do you know what Muwafaq al-Rubaie has been up to since he left his post as National Security Advisor?

4:37 PM, January 04, 2010

 
Blogger madtom said...

"And let’s get things started by asking, how will the protests in Iran be influenced by a successful and fair election in Iraq?"

What are the chances of that when O seems completely uninterested at best, and politically motivated for a disaster, so he can blame Bush. I mean his track record in Afghanistan, his "right war" wasn't that great, in fact a disaster.

7:25 PM, January 04, 2010

 
Blogger rr8004 said...

You share valuable information and excellent design you got here! I would like to thank you for sharing your thoughts and time into the stuff you post!! Thumbs up. Please come visit my site City Guide Phoenix when you got time.

9:01 PM, January 06, 2010

 
Blogger rr8004 said...

You share valuable information and excellent design you got here! I would like to thank you for sharing your thoughts and time into the stuff you post!! Thumbs up. Please come visit my site Philadelphia Business Directory when you got time.

9:01 PM, January 06, 2010

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thank You. Thank You. Thank You!

7:23 AM, January 08, 2010

 
Blogger rr8004 said...

Hello mate, I want to thank you for this nice blog. Would you mind telling me some secrets for a succesful blog ? Which could attract some visitors than it normally does. Please come visit my site Chicago City Directory when you got time.

8:32 PM, January 11, 2010

 
Blogger rr8004 said...

Hello mate, I want to thank you for this nice blog. Would you mind telling me some secrets for a succesful blog ? Which could attract some visitors than it normally does. Please come visit my site Phone Directory Of Chicago City Illinois IL State when you got time.

8:33 PM, January 11, 2010

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

How serious is the banning of candidates by the Election Commission? It stinks of Iran. Will it be corrected in time to avoid screwing up the election?

9:50 PM, January 16, 2010

 
Anonymous gj said...

Nibras - could you please give a run down on Dr Mutlak's biography, firstly his Baath history and secondly on the way he and his party have conducted themselves since the 2005 elections?

Have found it impossible to get this info to find out what is behind his exclusion?

As you can see the usual suspects -Lynch, the NYT etc are back making hay.

Appreciate it if you could emerge from yr lofty retirement and give yr loyal fans some enlightnment?

cheers gj

1:02 PM, January 18, 2010

 
Blogger Ed said...

Welcome back, i come here for info on Iraq, and correct you on one point. Many Americans are very interested in seeing your elections proceeding unimpedded, not just about withdrawing troops. We want to hear that things are getting better and freedom rings. Lastly are the refugees returning and how is it for them getting their properties back.
Thanks again for all your insight
Ed

1:39 AM, January 24, 2010

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

TOSHIBA PA3400U-1BRS Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PA3399U-1BRS Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PA3399U-2BAS Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PA3400U-1BAS Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PA3400U-1BRL Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PA3400U-1BRL Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PA3478U-1BAS Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PA3478U-1BRS Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PABAS057 Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PABAS076 Laptop battery
TOSHIBA PABAS077 Laptop battery
SONY VGP-BPL2C Laptop battery

11:42 AM, August 03, 2010

 
Blogger watches lover said...

2011 new shoes, power balance, watches, sunglasses, handbags online
Up to 70% off, free shipping

Power balance wholesale .
Welcome to Online shop for barbour jackets sale and Power balance

6:47 PM, November 26, 2010

 
Blogger watches lover said...

Ugg boots, Ugg outlet, 70% off, Cheap ugg boots sale online

Ugg boots clearance

winter boots

1:59 AM, January 05, 2011

 
Blogger watches lover said...

nike running shoes

ecco shoes,discount ecco shoes,60% off,ecco shoes on sale

golf equipment

reebok zigtech

2:00 AM, January 05, 2011

 
Anonymous Astermeds.com said...

Hello,
This is great blog post found here, Keep posting such an interesting blog post. Thanks!

5:03 AM, July 22, 2011

 
Blogger MulberryNews said...

Acquiring mentioned Oakley Sunglasses Outlet of which, this vftbieg is actually an clue towards typical individuals who qualified Half X aren't the pot connected with tea. But not Oakley Stpl Jawbone to ever get nervous as there may be commonly an answer for many problem. Replica or maybe not high-priced Oakley Jawbone are the warm stuffs this holiday season, that is probably acquiring big recognition throughout Sale Oakley Sunglasses the typical part on the society. These Oakley Sunglasses Discount reasons damage on your delicate little brown eyes. Comparing having other Half X Oakley, the Oakley Sunglasses Cheap are considerably more effective in addition to let considerably more versatile fun of apparent support in addition to vision safeguard.

9:01 PM, July 22, 2011

 
Blogger MulberryNews said...

Isn't really that will easy? naturally vytrqpn of course. Developing Oakley Sunglasses Cheap a most up-to-date health professional Half X Oakley prescribed taking place, you'll be able to decide on which ever Oakley Sunglasses Discount that suits you, along with the opticians will likely present you with Sale Oakley Sunglasses a number of idea what is the best form of economical Oakley Jawbone go well with your current eye-sight just. These are plenty Oakley Stpl Jawbone cheaper when compared with those with your enterprise look, considering that opticians aren't required to commit your enable through Half X the residences. numerous folks could possibly speculate set up quality involving Oakley sunglasses can be confirmed. The Oakley Sunglasses Outlet tend not to actually represent large explanation solution.

2:21 AM, July 25, 2011

 
Blogger MulberryNews said...

The many types of vbaghnm wrapa Oakley Frogskins get not deserted their fashion along with acceptance. This summer, your wrapa Oakley Frogskin using complete along with fine design and style happens returning straight into fashion yet again, containing depicted your riches along with high-class involving girls frankly. Firmoo's give back along with repayment insurance would likely create your current obtain using Firmoo risk-free. examine out and about each of our $8 Cheap Oakley Sunglasses, $10 along with thirty greenback Oakley Jawbone support frames to suit your funds along with sight requires. Since first design Oakley Jawbones, these are acknowledged by simply numerous men and women.

2:24 AM, July 26, 2011

 
Blogger Half X Oakley said...

You may want to track vgebhty down nicely made Oakley Sunglasses Cheap using excellent skiing conditions helmets Half X Oakley for you to supplement his or her sporty search. There exists merely one Oakley Sunglasses Discount pertaining to shopper decide on as part of your past Sale Oakley Sunglasses ages. Effectively, the idea tend not to visual appeal that will desired somehow. Nevertheless Oakley Jawbone right now, customers employ a a lot superior alternative: Oakley Stpl Jawbone. Half X while their concept demonstrates could make the thing is that evident though preserving way up your current sight via Oakley Sunglasses Outlet highly effective sun rays.

11:36 PM, July 26, 2011

 
Blogger 汪先送 said...

which will be recorded this weekend,so lotro gold and hopefully available online early next week. I have been listening to these two teachers from Kansas City, MO, for quite awhile now. wow gold cheap

2:44 AM, October 29, 2011

 
Anonymous wedding dresses said...

Article is very interesting,thanks for your sharing.I will visit this site.And welcome to wedding dresses online shop.We supply high quality wedding dress,

1:14 AM, November 17, 2011

 

Post a Comment

<< Home