Unconventional thinking about the Middle East.

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Nir Rosen: End of the Sunni Insurgency

I've had my issues with Nir Rosen's past reporting, but his piece slated for tommorow's issue of The National (UAE) requires careful mulling over by those who've followed Iraq closely over the past few years. For long-time readers of Talisman Gate, this article may come to be viewed as a vindication for what I've been arguing since autumn 2006.

Excerpts from 'The Big Sleep':
What has not followed the drop in violence is a political settlement: for the past year analysts have worried that the failure to disarm or integrate the Sunni Awakening groups into the state risked sowing the seeds of a new insurgency. But the tepid response to the arrest of Mashhadani and other Awakening men suggests that a political reconciliation may not have been necessary. The burgeoning Iraqi state, embodied by Maliki himself, can simply continue to expand its power and crush any rivals. One US Army Iraq expert, who worked closely with General David Petraeus to plan and implement the surge, told me in 2008 that the civil war would end when the Shiites realised they had won and the Sunnis realised they had lost. Based on the conversations I had during a trip through Iraq last month, both sides seem to accept that this is the case...

There is nothing the Awakening groups can do. As guerrillas and insurgents they were only effective when they operated covertly, underground, blending in among a Sunni population that has now mostly been dispersed. Now the former resistance fighters-turned-paid guards are publicly known, and their names, addresses and biometric data are in the hands of American and Iraqi forces. They cannot return to an underground that has been cleared, and they still face the wrath of radical Sunnis who view them as traitors. They have failed to unite and as their stories demonstrate, they are on the run.


Anonymous Jon Claerbout said...

Although many claim the surge is what turned the tide, I wonder if it wasn't the electric drill. I.e. the Shia didn't counter attack with munitions, because they were overgunned. But then they found the electric drill and for the first time the Sunnis got back what they were dishing out.

3:06 PM, April 23, 2009

Blogger Nibras Kazimi نبراس الكاظمي said...

Hi Jon,

These two columns may answer your question:




3:19 PM, April 23, 2009

Blogger ahmed said...

very good.

5:24 PM, April 23, 2009

Anonymous gj said...

Well that's going to send a rocket around the US armchair Sunni Arabists. Will have to pin their hopes on an Iraq army coup overthrowing the representative, democratic constitution. Alternatively, Maliki the evil one, usurps all power to himself? What's your guess, Nibras?

5:55 PM, April 23, 2009

Anonymous CMAR II said...


It's awful gracious of you not to mention that while you were being mocked for saying the Sunni insurgency was collapsing, Nir Rosen literally SAT on information that the insurgents had told him that it had already collapsed.

And he sat on that information for 2 1/2 years.

10:42 PM, April 26, 2009

Anonymous Anonymous said...

the north facethe north face
north face jacketnorth face jacket
north face jacketsnorth face jackets
north facenorth face
north face outletnorth face outlet
North Face Mens JacketsNorth Face Mens Jackets
pandora pandora
pandora bracelets pandora bracelets
pandora charms pandora charms
Pandora BanglePandora Bangle
pandora charms braceletspandora charms bracelets
charm bracelets pandoracharm bracelets pandora
pandora bracelets ukpandora bracelets uk
links bracelet links bracelet
links london bracelet links london bracelet
links london charms links london charms
links charms links charms
charm bracelets charm bracelets
links bracelet sweetie links bracelet sweetie
charm links bracelet charm links bracelet
sweetie bracelet sweetie bracelet
links of london links of london
links london links london
ugg boots ugg boots
As Seen On TV As Seen On TV
Video Game AccessoriesVideo Game Accessories
Laptop Batteries Laptop Batteries
ed hardy clothing ed hardy clothing
Abercrombie And Fitch Abercrombie And Fitch
tiffany jewellery tiffany jewellery

1:59 AM, April 15, 2010

Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

chargers jerseys
nba jerseys
salomon shoes
true religion jeans
birkenstock sandals
cheap oakley sunglasses
red valentino
cheap jordan shoes
ed hardy

11:45 PM, March 23, 2017


Post a Comment

<< Home